6 Reasons Your Church Members Act Like Jerks

By Thom Rainer • September 27, 2016

Email this Print version

Thom Rainer: “Unfortunately, most church members don’t even realize they aren’t friendly to guests.”

Recent Stories

• Church Leaders, Are Your Decisions Missional or Emotional?
  “In a missional decision, every action and ministry function is done with a focus on the mission of Christ.”
  
• 4 Ways to Gauge Your Team’s Emotional Health
  Pete Scazzero: “In emotionally healthy teams, role expectations are openly talked about and agreed upon.”
  
• 6 Reasons Your Church Members Act Like Jerks
  Thom Rainer: “Unfortunately, most church members don’t even realize they aren’t friendly to guests.”
  

It’s one of the biggest lies in churches.
Of the thousands of on-site and virtual consultations I have done, it is the most common sentence I hear from church members:
“We are the friendliest church in town!”
With rare exceptions, it’s just not true.
We then surveyed guests who visited the church and found a dramatically different perception. Their most common comment is:
“The people at that church aren’t very friendly.”
So how do so many church members have such a disconnect with reality? I see six common reasons:

1. The Holy Huddle Syndrome

Church members naturally gravitate to people they know when they go to a worship service. They already have relational connections. The members thus perceive they are friendly because they are friendly to each other. Unfortunately, guests are not included.

2. The Stand-and-Greet Satisfier

Many churches have a time set aside in the worship service for people to greet one another. I have written before about the dreaded stand-and-greet time. For most church members, those three to four minutes of shaking hands and speaking to someone constitute friendliness. To guests, it often seems contrived and inconsistent with what they see beyond the “official” welcome time.

3. The “I Don’t Live Here” Reality

Church members know the facilities of their churches. They know where to park. They don’t need good signage. They know where to sit.
Guests are, well, guests. They often come to the worship services frustrated because of poor signage. One guest tried to open three doors before she found the right one. And she was a single mom with three kids in tow. For many guests, they form a quick opinion that the church is for insiders only.

4. The Insider Language Mystery

Often, those who preach or make announcements speak in words and acronyms that only members understand. It seems to be an insider code without any consideration to those who are making their first visit. The guest feels like he or she is on the outside looking in.

5. The Unhappy Kid/Unhappy Parent Problem

Regardless of the adults’ experience at church, if their children do not have a good experience, it will be clearly reflected in the parents’ attitudes. Some churches go out of their way to make the children safe, secure and happy. That’s good. Some don’t. That’s bad.

6. The 6+1 Dilemma

Most Christians are not prayerfully and intentionally trying to reach non-Christians through word and deed. How can we expect those members who don’t have a friendly attitude toward the outsider six days a week change it dramatically for one day a week? The truly friendly people I see in churches show love, concern, compassion and friendliness toward others the other six days of the week.
Guest friendliness is important. Indeed, it can make an eternal difference in the guests’ lives. But guest friendliness is not natural in most churches. And, unfortunately, most church members don’t even realize they aren’t friendly to guests.
It’s a problem. The first step is realizing how unfriendly your church may really seem to guests.
Read more from Thom Rainer »
Thom S. Rainer serves as president and CEO of LifeWay Christian Resources. Dr. Rainer can be found on Twitter (@ThomRainer) and at facebook.com/Thom.S.Rainer. This article was originally published at ThomRainer.com on Sept. 19, 2016.